PRO&CON® Extras
Pros and Cons of Banning Stock Trading in Congress
There is growing momentum in Congress to limit elected officials’ ability to buy and sell stocks while they serve in public office. Government watchdogs have long called for such a ban, but it took on new life after reports that several lawmakers may have profited from stock sales during the COVID-19 pandemic that could have been influenced by intelligence briefings. For example, Sen. Richard Burr (R-N.C.) was investigated by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) for stock trades he made shortly after he was briefed about COVID-19 in early 2020. Burr unloaded as much as $1.7 million of stocks following…
Read more...Pros and Cons of Closing Guantanamo Bay
More than 20 years after the 9/11 terrorist attacks and the onset of the war on terror, policymakers are still debating the need to house suspected terrorists at a U.S. detention center in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. Opened in January 2002 under then-President George W. Bush, the infamous detention center has been the source of much conflict. Proponents have argued that Guantanamo was and still is needed to protect Americans’ safety, while detractors question the facility’s practice of detaining individuals without judicial oversight and the legacy of controversial interrogation techniques that have violated the Geneva Conventions. Some Guantanamo detainees who have…
Read more...Pros and Cons of Eliminating the Debt Ceiling
In December 2021, Congress raised the nation’s debt ceiling by $2.5 trillion so that the federal government would not default on its financial obligations. President Joe Biden signed the bill into law, ensuring that the U.S. will make good on its fiscal commitments into 2023. However, the contentious lead-up to the bill’s passage left many questioning the effectiveness and necessity of a U.S. debt ceiling. Initially created to help constrain the nation’s borrowing, the U.S. debt ceiling defines the amount of money the U.S. government can borrow to pay its obligations, including Social Security and Medicare benefits; military and civilian…
Read more...Pros and Cons of Filibuster Reform
Momentum is building to eliminate the U.S. Senate’s filibuster rule. The tactic, which dates back to the beginnings of the Senate, requires 60 votes to end debate on a bill and advance to a final vote, essentially meaning that most bills require more than a simple majority vote to pass. Increasingly, however, the filibuster has become a tool used by the minority party to stall or block the legislative agenda of the majority party. For example, Senate Republicans used the filibuster several times in 2021 to block voting rights legislation. That’s prompted increasingly serious discussion among leading Democrats — including…
Read more...Pros and Cons of Ranked-Choice Voting
A group of lawmakers recently introduced legislation to advance a voting system that aims to end, or at least ameliorate, partisanship in U.S. politics. The Voter Choice Act (S. 2939), introduced by Sens. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.) and Angus King (I-Maine) and Rep. Dean Phillips (D-Minn.), would provide $40 million to help states and local governments to cover the costs of adopting a ranked-choice voting (RCV) model, also known as “instant-runoff voting.” Traditionally, most U.S.-based elections have followed the plurality system where candidates who receive the most votes win. Under this system, however, a candidate could receive as few as 34%…
Read more...Pros and Cons of the Equal Rights Amendment
In March 2021, the House voted to extend a deadline for ratifying the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA), which would formally ban discrimination on the basis of sex and has lingered in a state of limbo for decades. The joint resolution (H.J. Res. 17) passed the House in a 222-204 vote that fell largely along party lines. Four Republicans joined all Democrats in favor of the resolution, which was introduced by Rep. Jackie Speier (D-Calif.) and Rep. Tom Reed (R-N.Y.). The House passed a similar resolution in 2020, but the Senate, controlled by Republicans at the time, did not bring it…
Read more...Pros and Cons of Drug Sentencing Reform
Amid broader talks on criminal justice reform, lawmakers moved one step closer to eliminating the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine offenses. In September, the House passed the Eliminating a Quantifiably Unjust Application of the Law (EQUAL) Act (H.R. 1693), which would make the penalties for federal crack cocaine offenses equal to those of powder cocaine offenses. The bill would also apply those changes retroactively, so individuals currently serving prison sentences for crack cocaine offenses could be eligible to have their sentence times reduced. The bill passed in the House by a bipartisan vote of 361-66, receiving unanimous support…
Read more...Pros and Cons of Teaching Critical Race Theory
A movement in the U.S. that suggests that race is a social construct used to oppress minority groups is emerging as a fierce point of division among Americans. Many Republicans are pushing new policies to bar public schools from teaching critical race theory (CRT) and the issue has made its way into political campaigns. Originally developed through legal scholarship in the late 20th century, CRT is a concept that aims to explain how discrimination and inequity are woven into laws, policies and systems. Thus, the doctrine states, racism is perpetuated in American culture. The theory argues that racism goes beyond…
Read more...Pros and Cons of the Nord Stream 2 Pipeline
In spring 2021, President Joe Biden struck a deal with German Chancellor Angela Merkel to remove U.S. sanctions on a Russian company building a natural gas pipeline from Russia to Germany. While analysts suggested the move was made to protect U.S. relations with Germany, the decision was opposed by both Republicans and Democrats as well as several European countries. The Nord Stream 2 pipeline, constructed by the Russian state-controlled gas company Gazprom, is projected to double natural gas exports into Europe once German regulators certify the recently completed project. The pipeline runs under the Baltic Sea and bypasses Poland and…
Read more...Pros and Cons of the Hyde Amendment
As lawmakers negotiated annual government spending bills this summer and fall, federal funding for abortions emerged as a contentious issue. Democrats pushed for the removal of an annual appropriations rider known as the Hyde Amendment, which prohibits federal funding for abortions, while Republicans said they were committed to keeping it on the books. First enacted by Congress in 1976, the Hyde Amendment, named for former Rep. Henry Hyde (R-Ill.), means there is no coverage for abortions for Medicaid recipients and those who get health care through other federal programs like the Indian Health Service, Medicare and the Children’s Health Insurance…
Read more...